Easing the EU ETS: EU seeks compromise between competitiveness and climate goals

Easing the EU ETS: EU seeks compromise between competitiveness and climate goals shutterstock.com
Maria Semenova

The European Parliament is due to vote on the reform as early as December

Discussions on revising the rules of the EU Emissions Trading Scheme (EU ETS), initiated by the European Commission in July under pressure from industry, have intensified again in the European Union. Competitiveness concerns are gaining increasing influence over climate policy.

EcoPolitic has put together a digest of the latest news and trends in the transformation of the European emissions trading scheme. Read on to find out which forces are clashing over its easing and how significant the changes could be.

More free allowances for industry

On 12 November, the Council of the EU and the European Parliament reached a provisional agreement to increase the free allocation of allowances to energy-intensive industries for the period 2026–2030. The total volume of support will amount to around 121 million allowances.

The agreement covers companies in energy-intensive sectors at risk of carbon leakage. These include, in particular, producers of chemicals, paper, glass, ceramics and food products.

The deal is based on the European Commission's proposal, which provided for around 88 million allowances. A further 28 million allowances were added to this volume, which had previously not been allocated because certain companies failed to meet the requirements for energy audits or climate neutrality plans. Another 5 million allowances were reserved for targeted support to the sectors most vulnerable to the risk of production relocating outside the EU.

Unused allowances from the latter reserve will be channelled into supporting investment through the Modernisation Fund and innovative projects under the Innovation Fund.

The Council of the EU explains the decision by the need to protect European producers from so-called carbon leakage, the relocation of production to countries with less stringent climate requirements. At the same time, the agreement still has to be formally approved by the Council of the EU and the European Parliament.

Ireland proposes slowing down cuts to free allowances

Another step towards relaxing the ETS rules became known on 15 November. According to Reuters, Ireland, which currently holds the presidency of the Council of the EU, has proposed changes that could slow down the phase-out of free allowances for industry and exempt smaller installations from new decarbonisation requirements.

  1. One of the main proposals concerns the methodology for calculating industrial benchmarks, which determine the number of free allowances. According to the text, benchmarks would be based on the most efficient installations accounting for 10% of a sector's output, instead of the current method based on the 10% most efficient installations. Industry associations argue that the existing method allows a small number of exceptionally efficient plants to have a disproportionate influence on the benchmark.
  2. It is also proposed to update the benchmarks every year instead of reviewing them once every five years. This would make the reduction in free allowances more gradual.
  3. Other proposals would exempt small installations that received fewer than 5,000 free allowances in the previous period from the obligation to submit decarbonisation investment plans in order to qualify for free allowances.
  4. Large companies would be allowed to receive the final 20% of their free allowances as soon as construction of a decarbonisation facility begins, rather than after the project is completed.
  5. Companies may be allowed to pool decarbonisation investments within industrial clusters and value chains.

EU countries are due to discuss these proposals on Wednesday, 18 November. The Irish presidency aims to reach an agreement on the ETS revision at the December meeting of the EU Environment Council.

Not everyone supports easing climate requirements

Amid the debate on support for industry, some European businesses and civil society organisations are calling for ambitious climate targets to be maintained.

On 17 November, 8 chemical companies, an industry association and 10 civil society organisations published a joint appeal calling for the EU ETS not to be weakened. Their demands include keeping the planned phase-out of free allowances for products covered by the CBAM and strengthening the link between receiving these allowances and real investment in decarbonisation.

The signatories also call for revenues from emissions trading to be directed towards the development of cleaner industrial production and for demand for low-emission products to be stimulated.

German Chancellor Friedrich Merz has also spoken out against weakening the system. In his letter, he urged Brussels to stand firm on the EU carbon market reforms and reject further changes to its second phase. In the German leader's view, industrial competitiveness problems should be addressed, in particular, by supporting lower electricity costs rather than by weakening the emissions trading scheme itself.

German industrialists raised the issues of competitiveness and the green transition on 16 November at Germany's National Steel Summit 2026. They stressed the need to protect European producers and prevent carbon leakage. Federal Minister for Economic Affairs and Energy Katherina Reiche, for her part, said that the federal government and the federal states are allocating around €6 billion to support the technological transformation of the main steelmaking centres.

How the carbon market is reacting

The agreement on additional free allowances has already affected market sentiment. According to SEE Energy News, after the deal was announced, the price of December EU ETS allowance futures fell by 2.5% to €88.15 per tonne of CO₂.

This indicates that the market sees the increased supply of free allowances as one of the factors putting pressure on the cost of carbon. At the same time, prices are also influenced by other factors, including the situation on energy markets.

What next?

The EU is currently trying to strike a balance between protecting industry from high costs and meeting its climate commitments. However, increased free allocation, a slower reduction in the number of allowances and weaker requirements for companies could reduce the financial incentives to accelerate decarbonisation.

The next key milestones will be the discussion of the Irish presidency's proposals on 18 November and the December negotiations on the ETS revision. Their outcome will determine whether the rules of the European carbon market change significantly.

As a reminder, in early November more than 100 European businesses warned in a collective letter of the risk of factory closures as a result of the EU ETS reform. Earlier, in October, the Council of the EU and the European Parliament provisionally agreed to increase the number of reserve allowances in the European emissions trading market by 75%.

Related
EU generated 2.3 million tonnes of textile waste in just one year — Eurostat
EU generated 2.3 million tonnes of textile waste in just one year — Eurostat

Italy leads in both textile waste generation and textile recycling

Energy from the Earth's depths: EU backs global 2050 target at COP31
Energy from the Earth's depths: EU backs global 2050 target at COP31

The EU considers this type of energy reliable and environmentally clean

Total electrification: EU agrees to new COP31 target, but many countries hesitate
Total electrification: EU agrees to new COP31 target, but many countries hesitate

It is proposed to raise the current 20% share to 35% as early as 2035

The EU Council wants to give oil and gas importers a one-year delay in reporting methane emissions
The EU Council wants to give oil and gas importers a one-year delay in reporting methane emissions

Methane is the second most destructive greenhouse gas, but energy risks are outweighing the Union’s environmental ambitions