From 9 October, farmers must obtain a permit to produce compost: what are the risks

From 9 October, farmers must obtain a permit to produce compost: what are the risks shutterstock

Anna Velyka

Experts have found yet another contradiction in environmental legislation

From October 9, in order to make compost from manure, it is necessary to issue a waste treatment permit and order an environmental impact assessment (EIA). Obtaining these documents will take about a year and will cost approximately UAH 1.5 million. Without them, the agricultural producer finds himself outside the law.

The Association of Environmental Professionals (PAEW) warned about this.

The experts explained that according to the law of Ukraine "On by-products of animal origin, not intended for human consumption", adopted in 2015, the producer has the right to store, process and apply organic fertilizer to the fields without additional permits.

But it contradicts Art. 2 of the Law of Ukraine "On Waste Management", adopted in 2022. It states that "the effect of this Law does not apply to by-products of animal origin, not intended for human consumption, the circulation of which is regulated by the Law of Ukraine "On by-products of animal origin, not intended for human consumption", except for those to which incineration operations are applied, landfill or used for biogas and compost".

Accordingly, manure used for composting or biogas production now becomes waste and is subject to all the requirements of the waste management law. That is, in order to legally make compost from manure, it is now necessary to issue a waste treatment permit. To do this, it is necessary to develop an ATS in advance.

According to experts, the approximate term of issuing all these permit documents is 1 year, and the estimated cost of their production is 1.5 million hryvnias.

"It is more profitable for agriculture to apply manure, after its mandatory temporary storage, than to produce high-quality compost," the Association says.

Therefore, PAEW turned to the Ministry of Environmental Protection and Natural Resources of Ukraine with proposals "that will allow at least a temporary sectoral response to the collapse of the waste management sphere":

  1. Abolish the need to obtain a waste treatment permit for manure used in composting and biogas production.
  2. Abolish the need to obtain an OVD for manure composting.
  3. Abolish the need for mandatory registration of organic fertilizer from compost.

To justify their position, the specialists gave the following arguments:

  • manure composting is a natural process and should not be considered a harmful activity requiring a mandatory permit;
  • simplifying the composting procedure will contribute to the development of organic farming and the improvement of the environment;
  • in today's difficult conditions, the expenditure of huge funds for obtaining OVD has become an unbearable burden for many agricultural enterprises.

At the beginning of September, EcoPolitic warned that due to the short-term reform of the waste industry thousands of entrepreneurs will become criminals

Related
Climate change and Ukraine: how global warming has already affected the country
Climate change and Ukraine: how global warming has already affected the country

In Ukraine, water bodies are drying up, and traditional agricultural regions are losing their potential

There is no ideal candidate for NETS: experts’ views on the proposed draft laws
There is no ideal candidate for NETS: experts’ views on the proposed draft laws

Spoiler: the experts do not have a single clear favourite, but their list of necessary improvements turned out to be fairly unanimous

ETS in Ukraine: a detailed analysis of all draft laws, without any unnecessary commentary
ETS in Ukraine: a detailed analysis of all draft laws, without any unnecessary commentary

Four draft laws, one carbon market and billions in future revenue: we break down who stands to gain what

Deliberately setting fire to rubbish instead of managing waste: a community in Bukovina has been fined
Deliberately setting fire to rubbish instead of managing waste: a community in Bukovina has been fined

The environmental inspectorate has detected signs of deliberate arson, but the authorities are blaming it all on unidentified local residents