How to collect eco- and macroeconomic losses from russia

How to collect eco- and macroeconomic losses from russia mepr.gov.ua
Katerina Belousova

It is critically important to correctly assess the extent of damages and develop a methodology for their assessment

Ukraine will be able to receive compensation only if it properly collects and documents the evidence that confirms the losses and proves the cause-and-effect relationship between the aggression of the russian federation and these losses.

Sofia Kosarevych, an analyst at the Dniester Center, wrote about it in an Economic truth's column. 

She noted that due to military aggression in Ukraine fall in GDP according to the results of 2022, it may reach 35-40%. The country also faced theft and destruction of natural resources and agricultural products, in particular grain and wood .

"Reimbursing these types of losses will be quite a difficult process. First of all, this is related to the documentation and confirmation of the authenticity of the losses and their assessment," he writes Kosarevych.

The Special Procedure for determining damage, which was approved by the Cabinet of Ministers, is quite general and mostly contains indicators on the basis of which damage will be calculated, in particular, GDP losses due to human casualties.

However, as international practice shows, this may not be enough. For example, the International Court of Justice of the United Nations in February 2022 ordered Uganda to pay Democratic Republic of the Congo compensation in the amount of $325 million. This amount is significantly less than the stated demands, which were put forward not only with regard to macroeconomics and natural resources.

"This decision is the latest in international practice regarding compensation. The approaches that were used in it are likely to be used in cases about compensation to Ukraine, even if they are considered by another body," said Kosarevych.

She also emphasized that it is important to make claims for different types of damage when compensating for war damages within the framework of existing international mechanisms. And it is extremely important for the government and the affected business to take into account the details of this case when developing a strategy for compensation.

"It is critically important to correctly assess the extent of damages and develop a methodology for their assessment. For this, it is worth involving recognized experts who will be able to provide the necessary justification and explain how these figures were obtained," the analyst said.

After all, any international body or mechanism that will award compensation will be based on specific and confirmed data, which should be carefully prepared. Therefore, political statements with big numbers are not enough to make reparations a reality.

"The government should develop a clear and understandable evaluation methodology based on the available evidence, on the basis of which it will be possible to demonstrate the connection between the actions of the Russian Federation and losses of the economy: both macroeconomic and natural resource losses," Kosarevych stressed.

She also noted that without these efforts, it will be difficult to get compensation, since even obvious things need to be proven.

Earlier, EcoPolitic wrote, according to the calculations of the Kyiv School of Economics, that Ukraine's land survey cost with a high risk of mine contamination and demining of the affected areas is estimated at $436 million.

As EcoPolitic previously reported, Ukraine is one of the most mined countries of the world, because almost a third of the area is about 200,000 square km need demining.

Tags: , ,
Related
Ukraine plans to amend its State Environmental Policy Strategy in view of the realities of war
Ukraine plans to amend its State Environmental Policy Strategy in view of the realities of war

The document also provides for preparedness for natural disasters caused by climate change

Birds killed by explosions near a nature reserve in Odesa region: how war threatens birdlife
Birds killed by explosions near a nature reserve in Odesa region: how war threatens birdlife

Birds' anatomy makes them extremely vulnerable to barotrauma – their blood vessels and hearts simply cannot withstand the pressure drop

Dangerous air pollution recorded in several Ukrainian cities on November 13
Dangerous air pollution recorded in several Ukrainian cities on November 13

The lowest pollution level is currently recorded in Uzhhorod

Ukraine at COP31: discussion of the National ETS and opening of the Ukrainian pavilion
Ukraine at COP31: discussion of the National ETS and opening of the Ukrainian pavilion

A draft law on the emissions trading system has been submitted to the European Commission for expert review. Which one remains unknown