The court refused to exclude the land from the "Protasiv Yar" nature reserve in Kyiv

The court refused to exclude the land from the "Protasiv Yar" nature reserve in Kyiv facebook.com/save.protas/
Maria Semenova

The private company insisted that it had legal rights to use the protected land

Two disputed land plots will not be excluded from the "Protasiv Yar" nature reserve in Kyiv. This decision was made by the Northern Commercial Court of Appeal, which dismissed the developer’s appeal.

This was reported by the Office of the Prosecutor General.

An attempt to seize a protected area

The company filed a lawsuit seeking to partially overturn the Kyiv City Council’s decision to establish the “Protasiv Yar” landscape reserve of local significance. The case involved two plots totaling 1 hectare, regarding which the plaintiff claimed to have the legal right to use the land but had not given consent for the plots to be included within the reserve’s boundaries.

Initially, the court of first instance ruled these claims unfounded, and later, following the company’s appeal, the appellate court upheld that ruling.

Ecological prosecutors' objections

The Specialized Environmental Prosecutor's Office raised a number of objections against the plaintiff's arguments. Environmental prosecutors insist that the company has no rights to the disputed land plots, including the right to construct multi-storey buildings there.

In the opinion of the prosecutors, any construction activities on protected natural areas are unacceptable, as they can cause irreparable harm to the local environment.

The court sided with the prosecutors.

It should be recalled that the Kyiv City Council approved the sale of land in the ravine back in 2000 for the construction of a multi-storey residential complex. The local community has actively opposed these plans, and in 2022, the Kyiv Council announced the creation of the "Protasiv Yar" landscape reserve.

However, as early as March 2026, a private company managed through court to exclude 16.5 ha from the protected area. As EcoPolitica reported, the court effectively deprived most of the reserve of its protected status.

The Prosecutor's Office disagrees with this decision; they stated that the company obtained these lands illegally. Therefore, prosecutors announced that they are considering the possibility of a cassation appeal to protect the "Protasiv Yar" reserve.

Related
Digest of environmental crimes of the week: pollution, forest felling and illegal subsoil use
Digest of environmental crimes of the week: pollution, forest felling and illegal subsoil use

Due to excessive discharge of mine water, an enterprise in Dnipropetrovsk Oblast has to pay over UAH 530 million

Years of stench and dead fish: residents of Poltava Oblast suffer from manure from a local farm
Years of stench and dead fish: residents of Poltava Oblast suffer from manure from a local farm

The waste is dumped just metres from vegetable gardens on former farmland

EU criticises corruption risks in Ukraine’s environmental sector and the merger of ministries
EU criticises corruption risks in Ukraine’s environmental sector and the merger of ministries

Construction projects that harm nature conservation areas which are not yet properly protected are also mentioned separately

Polluted a mountain river for years: hotel owner in Polianytsia given a ridiculously small fine
Polluted a mountain river for years: hotel owner in Polianytsia given a ridiculously small fine

The systematic discharge of sewage into the river "cost" the businessman only 85 thousand UAH