New rules on animal permits and stricter limits on trade: what the ministry proposes

New rules on animal permits and stricter limits on trade: what the ministry proposes shutterstock
Maria Semenova

The changes include a shorter list of permit documents and a ban on acclimatising wild animal species new to Ukraine's fauna

On 18 November, the Ministry of Economy, Environment and Agriculture of Ukraine put up for public consultation a document amending seven laws on the protection and use of flora and fauna. This was reported on the ministry's website.

Why updated rules are needed

The draft law "On Amendments to Certain Laws of Ukraine to Improve the Protection and Use of Fauna and Flora" is intended to bring the laws on fauna, flora and the Red Data Book of Ukraine into line with the legislation on administrative services and the permit system. Under that legislation, the key conditions of each permit must be set out in the law itself: whether a permit is required, who issues it, how long it is valid, which documents are needed and what the grounds for refusal are.

According to the ministry, without this it is impossible to approve new or update existing procedures for issuing permits, which are to be adopted by central executive authorities. A separate section of the draft law concerns liability for the animal trade.

Liability for animals and plants

The draft law supplements Article 63 of the Law "On Fauna". Under the document, liability will be established for:

  • illegally acquiring ownership of fauna objects, possessing them and keeping them in captivity or semi-free conditions, as well as exchanging, selling or offering them for sale, including online;
  • buying and selling animals that were previously acquired illegally by their former owners;
  • illegally sending, exporting them from Ukraine and importing them into its territory;
  • violating the import and export rules set out in legislation and international treaties of Ukraine.

In the comparative table, these provisions are presented as new. At the same time, the draft itself does not change the types of liability (administrative or criminal) or the amounts of sanctions.

There are fewer changes for plants: Article 40 of the Law "On Flora" merely rewords the existing ground relating to violations of import and export rules and adds a reference to international treaties. It says nothing about acquiring, possessing or selling plants.

What about confiscation

Animals and other fauna objects imported into or exported from Ukraine in breach of the law will be subject to confiscation.

Currently, the law provides for two options: confiscation or seizure free of charge. After that, they are sold according to the rules of the relevant ministry in agreement with the veterinary medicine authority.

The proposed draft law keeps only confiscation. Confiscated animals and other fauna objects are to be disposed of in line with the procedure for handling property confiscated by court decision and transferred to the State Enforcement Service. This procedure is established by the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine.

Which permits are enshrined in law

The draft law sets out the conditions for four types of permits:

  • Special use of animals (removal from the natural environment). The permit is free of charge and valid for one year. A decision to issue or refuse it is made within 30 calendar days. It is issued by the central executive authority for environmental protection within the approved limits. No limits are approved for rescuing animals in distress. Such a case must be reported to the supervisory authority, and a permit application must be submitted within five working days after the animal is removed. Separate laws apply to game, fish and Red Data Book species and to the nature reserve fund.
  • Import and export under the CITES Convention. The permit is free of charge. It is issued within 30 calendar days. If an opinion from the scientific authority is required, the period is extended by another 30 days. The validity period varies: 6 months for export from Ukraine, 12 months for import of species listed in Appendix I of the Convention, and 3 years for circuses and travelling exhibitions. For sturgeon and sturgeon products, the permit will still be issued by the fisheries authority. However, the rules for issuing it are being moved from the Law "On Fisheries" to Article 53 of the Law "On Fauna".
  • Special use of plant resources. The permit is issued within 30 working days and is valid for 1 year. For resources of national importance, the permit is free of charge. Permits of local importance will be issued by local councils in agreement with the regional state administrations and the Kyiv and Sevastopol city state administrations.
  • Special use of Red Data Book species. Such a permit is issued only in exceptional cases for scientific and breeding purposes, to which the draft adds the rescue of wild animals in distress. The permit is free of charge, valid for one year and issued within 60 calendar days on the basis of a decision by the National Commission on the Red Data Book. Use for profit remains prohibited.

Grounds for refusal are set for each permit, including an incomplete set of documents or false information if the applicant has not corrected them within the set period, as well as the absence of a limit. For CITES, a negative opinion from the scientific authority and decisions of the Convention's governing bodies are added, and for the Red Data Book, a decision of the National Commission. A permit is terminated at the holder's request, upon liquidation of a legal entity or termination of business activity, and also as a sanction under the Law "On Sanctions". In the event of refusal, the submitted documents are not returned to the applicant.

A shorter list of permit documents

Items 20, 21, 51 and 52 (permits to import/export flora and fauna objects, to breed Red Data Book species in captivity or semi-free conditions, and to relocate, acclimatise and crossbreed wild animals) are removed from the List of Permit Documents, while item 141 is extended to all specimens under the CITES Convention, not only sturgeon.

The ministry believes this will simplify the procedure for businesses and reduce the number of documents. At the same time, some of the requirements are moving to other provisions: breeding of Red Data Book species will fall under the permit under Article 19 of the Law "On the Red Data Book of Ukraine", and relocation within the natural range will fall under the general special use permit.

What will change for science, education, landowners and gatherers

In the Law "On Fauna", references to cultural, educational, upbringing and aesthetic purposes are removed from Articles 18 and 28. Scientific purposes and the relocation of animals remain. The draft also bans the acclimatisation of wild animal species new to Ukraine's fauna and the crossbreeding of wild animals for subsequent release into the wild. At present, this is allowed for research and economic purposes with the permission of the authorised body.

Another change concerns Article 17: the new wording no longer contains the provision that the permit requirement also applies to owners or users of land where fauna objects are located.

In the Law "On Flora", the second part of Article 9 on the rules for the general use of resources by citizens without permits is removed. However, citizens' right to gather medicinal raw materials, mushrooms and berries for their own needs is preserved in the first part, and the explanatory note does not comment on this change. Article 10 also removes "scientific needs" from the purposes of use, and the second part of Article 16 on the rules for using resources for research is deleted.

The Red Data Book and compensation

The National Commission on the Red Data Book will be required to publish its scientific justification 10 days before a meeting when it prepares changes to the species lists or a new edition of the book. In addition, the Cabinet of Ministers is given the power to set the procedure for indexing compensation for the illegal taking, destruction or damage of Red Data Book species and for the destruction or degradation of their habitats.

When the changes could take effect

If the law is adopted, it will enter into force the day after its publication. The Cabinet of Ministers will have three months to bring its own acts into line and ensure that ministries and other central executive authorities do the same.

EcoPolitic previously reported that the Ministry of Economy set up a 30-member working group to analyse current legislation on protecting animals from cruelty and prepare recommendations for amending it.

Related
Birds killed by explosions near a nature reserve in Odesa region: how war threatens birdlife
Birds killed by explosions near a nature reserve in Odesa region: how war threatens birdlife

Birds' anatomy makes them extremely vulnerable to barotrauma – their blood vessels and hearts simply cannot withstand the pressure drop

Culling of wild boars and predators allowed in Vinnytsia Oblast: how Ukrainians are reacting
Culling of wild boars and predators allowed in Vinnytsia Oblast: how Ukrainians are reacting

Hunters justify it by the need to prevent the spread of diseases, while people point out that civilised countries have long used humane methods that do not involve killing animals

Notorious Zakarpattia environmental inspectorate to be merged into a district body
Notorious Zakarpattia environmental inspectorate to be merged into a district body

This unit is known for its "blindness" to the destruction of Carpathian ecosystems for the construction of wind turbines and wind farm infrastructure

Digest of environmental crimes of the week: pollution, forest felling and illegal subsoil use
Digest of environmental crimes of the week: pollution, forest felling and illegal subsoil use

Due to excessive discharge of mine water, an enterprise in Dnipropetrovsk Oblast has to pay over UAH 530 million